These are the best four foundations I’d recommend after years of testing

Foundation is one beauty purchase you shouldn’t have to gamble on. I’ve worn, emptied and repurchased each of these formulas, while more than one has become a staple in professional makeup artists’ kits too. Consider this your shortcut to finding one you’ll invest in over and over again. 

As someone who has worn foundation almost daily for the better part of my adult life, I have a preference for lightweight, breathable foundation. For me, it’s about looking put-together without looking all the way made up.

The reason being that I don’t wear foundation to camouflage flaws, but to enhance my complexion and slightly conceal my (genetically) dark undereye circles. Plus, finding a formula that works beautifully with my skin is one of those small joys that makes switching between brands more of a hobby than a chore.

Speaking of; I’m due to replenish my go-to daily foundation, which is why I’ve been switching between tabs comparing which of my trusty favourites I should revisit at this time of the year.

If you’re in a similar shopping conundrum, the eternal question, of course, is light versus full coverage. Do you want to simply enhance your skin’s texture and tone or is serious camouflage what you’re after? The answer doesn’t have to be binary, and that’s precisely what this edit is here to prove.

I’ve spent years going back and forth between four of the most tried-and-tested foundations on the market, ranging from a drugstore darling that punches well above its price point to a velvet-smooth classic. Each one has been a faithful companion for months at a time (a bottle lasts me up to six months of regular use). That’s how good the coverage is: a little goes such a long way that I never need to layer heavily – by choice or otherwise.

I’ve arranged my top four picks from lowest to highest price, and each one genuinely has something brilliant to offer. Spoiler: the most expensive option is also the lightest (there’s a lesson in there somewhere).

ALSO READ: Sleep solutions that actually work: Our one-month test with two natural sleep aids

The budget hero: Revlon ColorStay Full Cover Foundation

Coverage: Full
Finish: Fully matte
Shade range: 16 shades

Beauty editor’s note: Few foundations have surprised me quite like this one. It delivers the kind of smooth, long-wearing full coverage you’d expect from prestige beauty, yet it has earned its place among my most-reached-for formulas.    

Price: R171 on Takealot.com 

I picked this up for the first time about three years ago on a whim during “mampara week” (those precarious few days leading up to payday) where I just couldn’t do without a lick of foundation. I was not prepared for how much the finish would actually impress me. The mousse-like texture is surprisingly lightweight — it doesn’t feel thick or heavy despite delivering full coverage – while the multi-mineral powder complex absorbs oiliness effortlessly.

The caveat, and it’s a modest one, is the shade range: 16 shades in the Full Cover version. I was fortunate enough to find my match — I’m somewhere in the middle — but I understand this is a limitation for many skin tones. Revlon, if you’re listening: please expand this range. You’ve built something special here, and many more makeup enthusiasts could benefit from this affordable option.

The reformulated classic: Estée Lauder Double Wear Stay-in-Place Foundation

Coverage: Medium-to-full, buildable
Finish: Natural matte (2026 reformulation)
Shade range: 70 shades (55+ widely available)
Beauty editor’s note: When longevity is non-negotiable, this remains the benchmark. The reformulation feels lighter and more modern, yet it still delivers the dependable, all-day wear that made it an icon in the first place. 

Price: R830 on Takealot.com

This is the foundation I’ve used the longest — it’s been in my life for years. I first picked it up in my early twenties, swiped from my mom. She has hyperpigmentation, and this foundation has managed to conceal it exceptionally well over the years — that’s how I discovered it, and that’s why it earned its place in the respective bathroom cabinets of my mom, sisters and of course, mine.

Similarly, Estée Lauder’s Double Wear (SPF 10) has held court as the world’s most beloved foundation for years on beauty shelves across the world, and its 2026 reformulation was created to defend that crown — not by reinventing the wheel, but by refining it into something sharper and more refined.

The texture is lighter, more fluid, and yet it builds just as well. Glycerin and hyaluronic acid will keep your skin comfortable rather than parched, and niacinamide alongside the brown algae extract and Balancing Complex with Alganiacin work to control oil without leaving that tight, matte-to-the-touch feeling.

Now, here’s one added vanity perk: of all four foundations in this comparison, Double Wear photographs the best when you’re wearing it. However, it’s also the one where I’m most aware I’m wearing foundation during the day. It’s not uncomfortable, and it doesn’t look heavy in any way, but I notice it in a way I don’t with the others. My skin is good — this is simply a product I know intimately after years of use, and that’s the one thing I’ve noticed.

It can also double as a concealer in a pinch, which speaks to the coverage this formula delivers.

A personal favourite: Lancôme Teint Idole Ultra Wear Foundation

Coverage: Full, lightweight yet buildable
Finish: Natural matte
Shade range: 45 shades

Beauty editor’s note: If you think full coverage has to feel heavy, Lancôme will change your mind. It delivers the polish of a high-performance foundation with the comfort of something far lighter, making it one of the easiest luxury formulas to wear from morning meetings to late dinners. 

Price: R850 | Arc Store, Bash.com, Edgars, Foschini, Superbalist.com, Woolworths

Here’s the thing about full-coverage foundations: they have a reputation problem. The phrase conjures images of thick, mask-like formulas that settle into every fine line, making your face feel cakey. Lancôme’s Teint Idole Ultra Wear exists to politely disagree, thanks to the Airwear technology that delivers something completely different. The texture is thin — almost serum-like — yet it builds to full coverage without any of the weight you’d expect. I’ve received compliments about this one from professional makeup artists in two different cities – true story.

The 81% serum base with hyaluronic acid and moringa means my skin feels moisturised rather than coated. SPF 35 is a bonus, making it an easy summer go-to when you want added protection over your SPF.

It’s waterproof, non-comedogenic, and I can reveal that it’s also sweat- and -humidity-proof (yes, I’ve kept it on in that quick transition from work to workout).

The effortlessly luminous MVP: Chanel Les Beiges Healthy Glow Foundation

Coverage: Light-to-medium
Finish: Luminous, healthy glow
Shade range: 39 shades

Beauty editor’s note: If your goal is to look like you’ve mastered your evening skincare routine, this is the one. It perfects rather than conceals, leaving skin looking rested, healthy and unmistakably radiant without ever appearing overdone.

Price: R1 350 | Chanel Beauty Boutique, Woolworths, Arc

I first discovered Les Beiges when I was living in Johannesburg, where the Highveld has a funny way of exposing every weakness in your skincare routine. That combination of altitude and dry air leaves skin perpetually thirsty, so a foundation that gives moisture back rather than steals it earns its place very quickly. Thanks to a formula rich in glycerin and meadowfoam-seed oil, this one never tips into greasy territory.

In terms of the shade match, it neither oxidises nor develops that tell-tale orange cast by mid-afternoon, and it remains remarkably true to your skin tone once you’ve found your shade.

What made this a satisfying product was also the reaction it gets in real life. People compliment me by telling my skin looks good instead of asking what foundation I’m wearing. That’s arguably the highest compliment a complexion product can receive. In a rare feat for a foundation, Les Beiges lets your skin take all the credit, while the antioxidant-rich formula protects it from pollution, free radicals, and blue light. It’s luxury in the most convincing sense of the word — not because anyone knows you’re wearing Chanel, but because nobody attributes your glow to a full makeup look at all.

ALSO READ: How are Love Island lips surviving all that kissing? We found the answer

Now make your pick:

Here’s what my time with these four foundations has taught me: the relationship between price and coverage isn’t linear. Chanel’s Les Beiges, the most expensive option at R1350, offers the lightest coverage and it’s glorious at what it does. The most affordable, Revlon’s ColorStay at just under R200, delivers the fullest coverage of the bunch and serious staying power.

If your skin runs oily or combination and you need something that will last, Estée Lauder’s Double Wear remains a fortress of reliability. If you want full coverage without the weight, Lancôme’s Teint Idole is the sophisticated choice that delivers on every promise.

The lesson? Know what you’re shopping for before you open your wallet.

All prices are accurate as of July 2026 but may vary by retailer. Available at select retailers including Edgars, Clicks, Bash.com, Woolworths, Takealot, and Arc Store.

This article was not sponsored but contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, ALL THAT will receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. All opinions expressed are those of the editorial team.